In Australian unfair dismissal law, the fact that there may be a valid reason for a dismissal is not dispositive that the dismissal was relevantly unfair.

“Valid reason related to capacity or conduct

[8]

In order to be a valid reason, the reason for the dismissal should be “sound, defensible or well founded”3 and should not be “capricious, fanciful, spiteful or prejudiced.”4 However,

1 Tyler Monaghan v Endacom Pty Ltd [2026] FWC 2079.

2 Sayer v Melsteel Pty Ltd [2011] FWAFB 7498, [14]; Smith v Moore Paragon Australia Ltd PR915674 (AIRCFB, Ross VP, Lacy SDP, Simmonds C, 21 March 2002), [69].

3 Selvachandran v Peteron Plastics Pty Ltd (1995) 62 IR 371, 373.

4 Ibid.

[2026] FWC 3507

3

the Commission will not stand in the shoes of the employer and determine what the Commission would do if it was in the position of the employer.5

[9]

Where a dismissal relates to an employee’s conduct, the Commission must be satisfied that the conduct occurred and justified termination.6 The question of whether the alleged conduct took place and what it involved is to be determined by the Commission on the basis of the evidence in the proceedings before it. The test is not whether the employer believed, on reasonable grounds after sufficient enquiry, that the employee was guilty of the conduct which resulted in termination.7

[10]

I find Mr Monaghan breached the obligations in his employment contract via posting messages on the engineers’ WhatsApp group from 12:40pm to 12:44pm which were extremely insulting towards his direct manager, Mr Sonogan. Although Mr Monaghan was not at work when he sent the messages, some of the recipients were at work and all the participants in the group were employees of Endacom. The chat was used to share work and personal information. In the circumstances, I consider Mr Monaghan’s conduct was sufficiently connected to his employment to constitute a breach of his employment contract. Although Endacom relied on this conduct as a breach of clause 15 of Mr Monaghan’s contract, that clause is directed at when the contract can be terminated by either party. I consider Mr Monaghan’s conduct is better characterised as a breach of his obligations as an employee as identified in clause 5 of the contract.

[11]

I also find Mr Monaghan breached the obligation in clause 16(b)(iii) of his employment contract not to encourage any employee of Endacom to leave their employment. I consider several messages Mr Monaghan sent from 12:32pm to around 1:00pm encouraged other employees in the chat to resign from their employment. While I do not consider it is remotely likely that Mr Monaghan’s messages would have been the primary trigger for any employee to resign, the obligation in the contract was not to encourage any employee to leave Endacom. I consider Mr Monaghan breached that obligation. While Mr Monaghan was not at work when he sent the messages, I consider the conduct had a sufficient connection to the workplace to allow a finding of misconduct for the reasons identified above.

[12]

I note it appears the primary trigger for the numerous resignations was that the engineers had concerns about their working conditions which they had raised with Endacom and the concerns had not been addressed. It is unsurprising that resignations would occur among educated workers that would likely to be able to find other comparable work in those circumstances.

[13]

I find there was a valid reason for Mr Monaghan’s dismissal because he committed serious breaches of his employment contract on 29 October 2025. Although the breaches I have identified were not identical to those specified in Mr Monaghan’s termination letter, the Commission can identify a valid reason that was not the valid reason identified by the employer.8

5 Walton v Mermaid Dry Cleaners Pty Ltd (1996) 142 ALR 681, 685.

6 Edwards v Justice Giudice [1999] FCA 1836, [7].

7 King v Freshmore (Vic) Pty Ltd Print S4213 (AIRCFB, Ross VP, Williams SDP, Hingley C, 17 March 2000), [23]-[24].

8 Commonwealth of Australia (Australian Taxation Office) T/A Australian Taxation Office v Shamir [2016] FWCFB 4185, [45] citing Shepherd v Felt & Textiles of Australia Ltd (1931) 45 CLR 359, 377-8.

[2026] FWC 3507

4

[14]

The existence of a valid reason for Mr Monaghan’s dismissal related to his conduct weighs in favour of finding his dismissal was not harsh, unjust, or unreasonable.”

Monaghan v Endacom Pty Ltd  [2026] FWC 3507 delivered 15 September 2026 per Crawford C