The National Employment Standards contain provisions which entitle many but not all employees to make requests for flexible working arrangements. This is how the Fair Work Commission deals with disputes in such cases.
“Consideration
[31]
There does not seem to be an issue between the parties that the applicant is in the category of employees entitled to request a flexible work arrangement.
[32]
There is also not an issue between the parties that the applicant has made a request for a flexible working arrangement. In essence, the facts and circumstances are such that in 2025 respondent was seeking to change the applicant’s pre-existing working hours which had been formalised in 2021. The respondent’s attempt to do so arose in the circumstances set out in paragraphs [11] – [21] above. In the period after, July 2025, the respondent put various options to the applicant as to how she could work the hours sought by the respondent. In response, the applicant sought to retain her current hours and requested work from home arrangements for the first 45mins and last hour of her Sunday shift (i.e., between 9:00 – 9:45am and between 4:15pm – 5:15pm). Given that the respondent does not put in issue that the applicant has requested a flexible work arrangement, I am prepared to proceed on the basis that she has done so. The respondent has refused to approve the applicant’s request.
[33]
Consequently, I turn to the question of reasonable business grounds. The term “reasonable business grounds” are the substantive ground referred to in the Act as the basis upon which an employer may refuse an employee flexible work request. This in turn is then the relevant standard under clause 6.2 of the Agreement. However, neither the Act nor the Agreement expressly define the term “reasonable business grounds” albeit the Act specifies a non-exclusive list of examples directed to the practical operational impacts on the business of accommodating the change in the employee’s working arrangements. In Paper Australia v May [2025] FWCFB 224, a Full Bench of the Commission said as follows regarding the meaning of the terms “reasonable business grounds”:
[52] Given the absence in the Act of an express definition, or an exhaustive list, of “reasonable business grounds”, it is necessary to give the phrase its natural and ordinary meaning. In the online Macquarie Dictionary, the term “reasonable” is relevantly defined as “1. endowed with reason. 2. Agreeable to reason or sound judgment. …” In the online Australian Oxford Dictionary, the term “reasonable” is relevantly defined as “2. in accordance with reason, not absurd”. The term “business grounds” is directed to the business justification. It directs attention to the effect of granting the request for a change to the working arrangements of an employee on the business in question.
[2026] FWC 3351
8
[34]
The respondent has two reasons for refusing the applicant’s request. Firstly, the respondent wishes to have staff working Sunday rostered hours consistent with the revised Visitor Centre opening hours of 10:00am – 4:00pm. Secondly, the respondent wishes to have two employees rostered to work at the Visitor Centre in the interests of health and safety.
[35]
In my view, both reasons each constitute a reasonable business ground. Each reason is a rational or sound reason related to the respondent’s operational requirements or obligations.
[36]
In relation to having rostered hours to be consistent with the revised Visitor Centre opening hours, this is entirely reasonable. The Visitor Centre is obviously a facility whose substantial purpose is to have members of the public access the centre during opening hours. Consequently, to have staff working hours more consistent with the opening hours of the Centre is entirely reasonable. The respondent requires the applicant to commence work at 9:45am on Sunday morning, which is 15 minutes before the Visitor Centre opens to the public. The applicant’s requested commencement time is 9:00am. Consequently, the applicant’s requested hours would have her starting work a full hour before the Visitor Centre opens to the public on a Sunday. In these circumstances, the respondent has a proper operational business justification to refuse the applicant’s requested flexible work arrangement.
[37]
In relation to health and safety, the respondent relies on various grounds. The principal ground is that it wishes to have two employees present at the Visitor Centre at all times. This is evidently done in the background of the previous occurrence of threatening behaviour of a person at or near the Museum Building and Visitor Centre. Even if the threatening conduct by this person was not presently occurring at the time of the request or the time the request was declined, it seems reasonable for the respondent to assess that having two people present at a public access facility at all times is consistent with the maintenance of employee health and safety. The Visitor Centre is a public access facility. The applicant points to other instances where the respondent has permitted persons to work on their own in other parts of its operations. The fact that the respondent may have done so, does not mean that it does not have reasonable business grounds to refuse the applicant’s request on the identified occupational health and safety ground. Furthermore, the applicant points to the fact that if her preferred hours of work were granted, she would be working prior to the opening of the Visitor Centre and could do so behind locked doors. However, this would effectively mean that the applicant’s hours of work on a Sunday morning would not be best aligned with the opening hours of the Visitor Centre. As I have noted in the above paragraph, the respondent has a reasonable business ground to refuse to grant the applicant’s request based on its desire to make working hours more consistent with the opening hours of the Visitor Centre.
[38]
The applicant also refers to her preferred work start time as being actuated by a need to assist her deal with certain sleep issues. The applicant considered that consistent start times would assist with her those sleep issues. This matter was raised by the applicant at the meeting with the respondent on 17 September 2025. The applicant’s preference to start times, motivated by a desire to better manage sleep issues, does not displace the respondent’s reasonable business grounds. I also accept that the respondent considered the applicant’s personal circumstances. I note that the respondent proposed option A.2 after the meeting on 17 September 2025 (see par [26] above).
[2026] FWC 3351
9
[39]
I note that at the conclusion of the hearing, the applicant referred to another personal circumstance relating to her preference for a routine to attend to the care of a pet during lunch breaks and that the pattern of hours that she seeks is more consistent with the maintenance of that routine. This matter had not previously been raised by the applicant with the respondent. Whilst I sense that the applicant cares deeply for her pet, which obviously reflects well on her, the preferred routine of the applicant cannot and does not displace the respondent’s reasonable business grounds.
[40]
In the circumstances, I determine that the respondent has reasonable business grounds for refusing to grant the applicant her requested flexible work arrangement.”
Mathews v Greater Shepparton City Council [2026] FWC 3351 delivered 3 September 2026 per Farouque DP
